Dumb and Dumber: 5 Common Errors with Comparatives and Superlatives
Adjectives and adverbs come in three degrees of comparison: positive, comparative, and superlative. When comparing or contrasting two or more things, we use the comparative or superlative degrees. The following chart gives some examples of adjectives and adverbs in their various degrees.
positive |
comparative |
superlative |
adjectives |
||
happy |
happier |
happiest |
smart |
smarter |
smartest |
beautiful |
more beautiful |
most beautiful |
good |
better |
best |
bad |
worse |
worst |
adverbs |
||
sweetly |
more sweetly |
most sweetly |
gladly |
more gladly |
most gladly |
carefully |
more carefully |
most carefully |
well |
better |
best |
When using these modifiers in comparisons, avoid the following common errors.
Confusing Comparative and Superlative
Rule: When comparing or contrasting two persons, places, or things, use the comparative degree. When comparing three or more, use the superlative degree
Comparing two: On most women, evening gowns look more attractive than overalls.
More than two: Of all the electricians I know, you are the most attractive.
Comparing two: Marvin is wiser than Tom, but Tom is kinder.
More than two: Solomon was the wisest man of all.
A common error occurs when the degrees are confused:
Confused: Between Larry and Moe, Moe is the meanest.
Better: Between Curly and Moe, Moe is the meaner.
Doubling Up
In forming comparative and superlative modifiers, you either add an er/est ending or add the helpers more/most. It is never necessary to use both:
Incorrect: That was my most happiest moment.
Correct: That was my happiest moment.
Incorrect: This restaurant is more better than the other.
Correct: This restaurant is better than the other.
Unbalanced Comparisons
Be sure that the items you compare are of a similar kind.
Unbalanced: Mrs. William’s tests are easier than Mr. Olsen.
Balanced: Mrs. Williams tests are easier than Mr. Olsen’s [tests].
Unbalanced: This coffee is better than the shop on main street.
Balanced: This coffee is better than the coffee in the shop on Main Street.
Not Using Other and Else
When comparing one of a group with the rest of the group, remember to use other or else.
Illogical: Greg was more trustworthy than any student in class.
Logical: Greg was more trustworthy than any other student in class.
Illogical: Bill is faster than anyone on the team.
Logical: Bill is faster than anyone else on the team.
Confusing Less and Fewer
When making negative comparisons, use the adjectives less and fewer. Increasingly these words are used interchangeably, but the traditional standard usage made a distinction that you should at least be aware of.
Traditional: Use less when comparing amounts and fewer when comparing numbers of things that can be counted.
Aunt Martha has less patience than Uncle Henry. (Patience can’t be counted.)
Aunt Martha knows fewer jokes than Uncle Henry. (Jokes can be counted.)
*****
Like this article? Please consider sharing it or subscribing to our weekly email update! Post any comments and questions below. Bloggers love comments.
Thank you so much. It helps a lot 🙂
I do not see the most common mistake which is to say things like more clear instead of clearer.
Because that’s not a mistake.
Thank you!
It was very helpful!
so what’s the definition of a confusing comparison?
I don’t know. I address the error of confusing comparative superlative pronouns.
Thank you so much. I love having these resources available.
Chantal
Good question Chatal. Yes, “even” is common before a comparative. It adds a kind of emphasis. It implies that the “comparee” is an outstanding example of the quality in question, but the “compared” is greater still.
“I am even happier than Sue” implies that Sue is exceptionally happy.
Is the use of even before a comparative acceptable?
I am even happier than Sue.
Is it doubling up? Implied or adds emphasis?
Merci